Mmmm Pie

Filed under: College Life, Contests and Promotions - BookRenter Team
Tags: , , , ,

In celebration of Thanksgiving we decided to do some pie taste testing. Who can resist the yummy goodness of pie.  With the endless variety of pies available especially around Thanksgiving it was hard to narrow it down to only four varieties for tasting- but we managed.

Pie Tasting, Yum!

Our offerings consisted of apple, pecan, chocolate cream, and pumpkin pie!

So what pie was the winner?

Apple Pie

Pumpkin Pie

The office thought Apple pie was the best and our Facebook fans felt that Pumpkin pie was their favorite. Once again we have disagreed with our fans on this one, but who cares. With the mass variety of pies out their were bound to have different opinions.

What’s your favorite pie?

41 Responses to Mmmm Pie

  1. Dana Noga says:

    Pumpkin….hands down! :p

  2. Paula Smith says:

    Sweet potatoe pie is where it’s at!

  3. Tawanda Green says:

    Pumpkin pie ftw! It beats all!!! 😀

  4. Angel Howman says:

    All of them! 😉 Especially Pumpkin and Pecan.

  5. Wendy S says:

    Well between the two… definitely pumpkin (it’s my second all time favorite) My all time favorite pie is Pecan Pie!

  6. Melissa Brecosky says:

    I died and went to heaven

  7. Melissa Brecosky says:

    Ohhh………….. over the pumpkin pie that is.

  8. Rachel Nixon says:

    Mmm Chocolate cream!

  9. Jennifer York says:

    sorry but that apple looks sooo good 🙂 LOVE ME some apple pie 🙂

  10. Brittany says:

    Pumpkin pie 🙂

  11. Summer says:

    Pumpkin is the best

  12. Kristin says:

    pecan and pumpkin! 🙂

  13. Mary McMenamy says:

    pumpkin for sure i am drooling how attractive is that

  14. Janene Scarborough says:

    Pumpkin! hands down! 🙂

  15. Lynski46157 says:

    Apple Cranberry!

  16. Assia M says:

    mmmm pumpkin pie!!

  17. Yen Nguyen says:

    peach pie 🙂

  18. Arena thompson says:

    Pecan pie is always my favorite! Save for cherry but i never see that on the thanksgiving menu 😉

  19. dallas n says:

    apple pie with caramel and vanilla ice cream

  20. victor gonzalez says:

    fav pie has to be, banana pie! 🙂 mud pie is pretty close

  21. Linda Dea says:

    I love me some chocolate pie!

  22. Becky Cole says:

    I’ve always been partial to blueberry pie!

  23. Loan Le says:

    Toss up between strawberry rhubarb and apricot.

  24. jennifer beck says:

    if i have to choose from your 4, it would be chocolate cream! otherwise, i choose my grandmother’s butterscotch pie. think i’m gonna make some right now!

  25. Kristen Grabeel says:

    Gotta go with Pumpkin! It’s tradition 🙂

  26. celin says:

    Pumpkin pie

  27. Joann Bally says:

    That’s a silly question
    (of course)

  28. robyn says:

    definately pumpkin. cant go wrong with pumpkin pies……ever!

  29. Jeannette A. says:

    Pumpkin’s the best, naturally! 😛

  30. Kevin Bell says:

    Gotta be Pumpkin Pie! Especially with a big dab of whipped cream on top!

  31. Hung says:


  32. tina says:

    ummm… apparently your blogger is having a sugar rush and forgot to get a copyeditor. It’s “out there” not “out their”! homonyms, people, check your homonyms. 🙂

    • tina says:

      and “we’re” not “were”!! there should be some punctuation there too; how about a semicolon?

  33. Elizabeth says:

    Looks delicious! I can’t wait for Thanksgiving!

  34. Roseanne Alonso says:

    Pumpkin bread!

  35. Dana Rodriguez says:

    I don’t care for Pumpkin at all but I sure do love apple pecan!

  36. Billie says:

    Apple pie!!! mmmmm

  37. Sue Goodin says:

    Chocolate cream

  38. Shelley says:

    I love blueberry pie. Thanks

  39. Pamela Hansen says:

    toss up between mincemeat and boysenberry